======================
#lightning-dev Meeting
======================


Meeting started by cdecker at 18:59:45 UTC.  The full logs are available
at
http://www.erisian.com.au/meetbot/lightning-dev/2019/lightning-dev.2019-01-21-18.59.log.html
.



Meeting summary
---------------

* Meeting agenda can be found here: http://bit.ly/ln-agenda-201902
  (cdecker, 19:00:17)
* PR #491: BOLT #2: order htlc_signatures by BIP69 + increasing CLTV.
  (cdecker, 19:04:56)
  * ACTION: BlueMatt to inline BIP69 into the BOLT to remove ambiguities
    (cdecker, 19:08:40)
  * ACTION: cdecker to merge #491  (cdecker, 19:12:24)
  * ACTION: The test vectors in #539 need to be verified independently.
    Decision is to be deferred until the next meeting  (cdecker,
    19:13:27)

* PR #500: BOLT 7: Add note for 'htlc_minimum_msat' being static
  (cdecker, 19:13:52)
  * ACTION: roasbeef to amend PR #500 to remove the static definition or
    open a new PR to do that  (cdecker, 19:20:38)

* PR #519: BOLT 7: add extended channel queries  (cdecker, 19:21:16)
  * ACTION: sstone to rework #519 with the feedback on the PR  (cdecker,
    19:36:55)

* PR #538: BOLT 4: Report outgoing HTLC values when appropriate
  (cdecker, 19:37:11)
  * ACTION: sstone to merge #538  (cdecker, 19:57:00)

* PR #544: BOLT 4: remove incorrect_payment_amount altogether.
  (cdecker, 19:57:10)
  * ACTION: cdecker to merge #544  (cdecker, 19:58:50)

* PR #545: BOLT 4: include `channel_update`'s message type  (cdecker,
  20:00:34)
  * ACTION: sstone to rephrase the PR to include what to do when type is
    unknown, everybody to discuss lively on the PR  (cdecker, 20:10:20)

* PR #546: Clarify behavior of id field in update_add_htlc  (cdecker,
  20:10:31)
  * ACTION: cdecker to merge PR #546  (cdecker, 20:12:45)

* PR #547: Keep HMAC case consistent  (cdecker, 20:12:54)
  * LINK: https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2104  (roasbeef, 20:14:20)
  * ACTION: BlueMatt to comment about the shed color not being uppercase
    (cdecker, 20:14:56)

* PR #548: Align offered and received HTLC scripts similarly  (cdecker,
  20:15:07)
  * ACTION: cdecker to merge #548  (cdecker, 20:16:12)

* PR #550: dpl: concretely define `my_current_per_commitment_point`
  (cdecker, 20:16:19)
  * ACTION: roasbeef to help with the wording of the PR to remove any
    remaining uncertainty  (cdecker, 20:21:27)

* PR #552: Demand revoke_and_ack before more updates  (cdecker,
  20:21:35)
  * ACTION: Defer #552 to the tracker  (cdecker, 20:24:10)

* TLV format and multi-hop onion  (cdecker, 20:28:47)
  * ACTION: cdecker to review lightningnetwork/lightning-onion#31
    (cdecker, 20:29:03)



Meeting ended at 20:31:22 UTC.



Action items, by person
-----------------------

* BlueMatt
  * BlueMatt to inline BIP69 into the BOLT to remove ambiguities
  * BlueMatt to comment about the shed color not being uppercase
* cdecker
  * cdecker to merge #491
  * cdecker to merge #544
  * cdecker to merge PR #546
  * cdecker to merge #548
  * cdecker to review lightningnetwork/lightning-onion#31
* roasbeef
  * roasbeef to amend PR #500 to remove the static definition or open a
    new PR to do that
  * roasbeef to help with the wording of the PR to remove any remaining
    uncertainty
* sstone
  * sstone to rework #519 with the feedback on the PR
  * sstone to merge #538
  * sstone to rephrase the PR to include what to do when type is
    unknown, everybody to discuss lively on the PR
* **UNASSIGNED**
  * The test vectors in #539 need to be verified independently. Decision
    is to be deferred until the next meeting
  * Defer #552 to the tracker



People present (lines said)
---------------------------

* cdecker (126)
* roasbeef (73)
* BlueMatt (42)
* sstone (30)
* bitconner (27)
* lndbot (13)
* rusty (6)
* lightningbot (2)
* kanzure (1)



Generated by `MeetBot`_ 0.1.4